Origin of “Man Does Not Live By Bread Alone”

Today, when we say “man does not live by bread alone”, we simply mean that humans need more than the basic necessities to live, whatever those other things may be. Usually, we are speaking of abstract “spiritual” needs as opposed to material ones. This expression is an ancient one and actually comes from the Bible. This proverb is found in two places in the Bible, both in the Old and the New Testament. In Deuteronomy 8:3: “Man doth not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of the Lord.” (Read the entire chapter). And also in Matthew 4:4: “It is written, Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.” (Read the entire chapter)

bread with fronds of wheat

We can take bread to mean “food” or all basic necessities, today, but we have lost the second part of the proverb in the modern expression, and not all people are thinking of God or religion when they use the proverb.

This expression has been repeated many times in literature. Nietzche mocked it in Thus Spoke Zarathustra (1885), saying, “man does not live by bread alone, but also by the flesh of good lambs.”

Whereas Nietzche, by bringing up the meat of lambs, was making fun of those who would follow the word of the bible like willing sheep, Dostoevsky took a more pious and liberal view of the passage. In a letter to a subscriber to his Diary of a Writer, he wrote:

…Contemporary socialism in Europe, even our own, is completely separated from Christ; is it concerned almost completely about bread; it looks to science and declares that the cause of all man’s miseries is poverty alone, the struggle for existence, the “environment tangle.”

To this Christ answered: “Man does not live by bread alone”—that is, spoke the axiom of the spiritual origin of man. The idea of hte devil could be suitable only to a man-brute; Christ knew that is was not brad alone that would give man life. If, furthermore, there is no spiritual life, no dieal of Beauty, then man will pin away (zatoskovat’) and ide, lose his mind, kill himself or give himself over to pagan fantasies. But since Christ, in Himself and in his Word, is the ideal of Beauty, he decided: it is better to inspire man’s soul with the ideal of Beauty; possessing it in their souls, all men become brothers and then, finally, working for each other, they also become prosperous. But give them bread and from boredom they will become the enemies of one another.

This viewpoint is more in line with the modern usage of the expression, which is to say that man does not live by bread alone, or simply by his material needs being met. Man needs a spiritual existence, love, beauty, art, brotherhood, and many other things that could be taken together as defining a “meaningful existence.”

The word bread is used many times in the bible, but not always with the same meaning. Jesus refers to himself, for instance as “the bread of God” and “the bread of life,” at least according to John chapter six:

Then Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Moses gave you not that bread from heaven; by my Father giveth you the true bread from heaven. For the bread of God is he which cometh down from heaven, and giveth life unto the world. Then said they unto him, Lord, evermore give us this bread. And Jesus said unto them, I am the bread of life; he that cometh to me shall never hunger; and he that believeth on me shall never thirst. – John 6:26 – 35

Many times, the exact intent of the word is debated. In the expression “man does not live by bread alone”, bread seems to not only stand for food, but for all material needs, including clothing or money.

The familiar biblical phrase “bread is the staff of life” seems to use bread to mean food in general. On the other hand, “cast your bread upon the waters and after many days you will find it again” seems to use bread to denote anything of material value. At other times, the word bread literally means bread.

More Food Idioms

breaking egg on forehead

Why Do We Say “Egg On Your Face” To Mean Looking Foolish?

Have you ever had egg on your face? Possibly, after eating eggs. But someone having egg on their face is also an idiomatic expression meaning...
first date going dutch reaction

Why Do we Call it “Going Dutch” When People On a Date Pay Their Own Way?

When friends go out to dinner together, unless it is a special occasion where previous arrangements have been made, it is customary, and considered proper...
vintage kool-aid package label

Why Do People Say “Don’t Drink the Kool-Aid?”

Every once in a while, you may hear someone say, “Don’t drink the Kool-Aid.” When they say it, it doesn’t sound as innocent as what...

Where Does ‘Land of Milk and Honey’ Come From?

The phrase ‘land of milk and honey’ is an idiomatic expression used today to refer to a place full of comfort and luxury. It is...

What is the Origin of the Baker’s Dozen?

Although it is not as widely practiced today as it once was, you can still find bakeries or bagel shops that, as a matter of...
pouring gravy

What Is Origin of the Word Gravy and Gravy Train?

The name of a dog food and the subject of at least one blues song by W.C. Handy, gravy train is a slang term which refers to...
giving each other the cold shoulder

What does Giving Someone the Cold Shoulder Have to do With Food?

The idiom, to give someone the cold shoulder, meaning to snub them or treat them with aloofness, has been in use at least since the 1800s. If...
three martinis

Three-Martini Lunch: Who Coined the Phrase?

A Three-martini lunch refers to a business lunch where martinis or other alcoholic cocktails are ordered. Since the lunch is business-related, it is used as a...
pie in the sky

Pie in the Sky: Where Did This Expression Come From?

Pie in the sky is an expression of cynicism. It has various shades of meaning, but it basically refers to an idea or dream that...

You May Be Interested in These Articles