Should You Use a Garlic Press?

This article may contain one or more independently chosen Amazon affiliate links. See full disclosure.

Most home cooks view a garlic press as an alternative to chopping or mincing garlic. They use it because they don’t want to go to the trouble of using a knife. Unfortunately, chefs and other experts don’t help. They tell us to use the garlic press if we’d like, or to never use it at all! Should you use one or not?

Garlic Press Is Not the Same As Chopping

A garlic press is not a must-have for most home cooks. When used, a press is not interchangeable with a knife. It has some utility in specific circumstances, but for most garlic uses, a chop or mince with a knife should be preferred as it will yield much better results.

garlic press with garlic

When you use a garlic press, you are crushing and juicing the garlic. This will release more of the sulfurous compounds and make for a much stronger, and perhaps bitter and unpleasant garlic taste. A fine chop with a knife will produce a lively pleasant garlic flavor, given the same amount of garlic.

Therefore, the majority of the time, it is better to use a knife to chop garlic and avoid the garlic press. This does not meant that a garlic press is never useful but it will always produce a stronger taste than using a knife.

How The Garlic Press Works

A garlic press forces cloves of garlic through tiny holes, thus crushing the garlic and forcing out the juice. It is no less trouble than a knife as, once you press the garlic through the holes, you will probably have to use a knife to scrape the garlic off the bottom of the garlic press. There may also be some garlic left on the inside of the pressing bowl. You may have to gather what is left and re-press it. Cleaning the garlic press is more difficult as the garlic gets caught in all the tiny holes.

using garlic press closeup

When To Use A Garlic Press

A garlic press is most useful when you need to incorporate or almost dissolve garlic into a mixture. Press garlic when you need to use it in a smooth but garlic-heavy sauce.

A garlic press is also best to use for making garlic butter, whether for use as part of a compound butter or for making garlic bread.

Most of the time, you will not use more than one or two cloves of garlic when using a press. This will give a pronounced garlic presence without being overwhelming.

chopped garlic

If You Don’t Have a Garlic Press, Do This

If you need to crush garlic into a paste, but don’t have a garlic press, do it like the old-school chefs: use salt and a knife. Place a bit of salt onto a few cloves of garlic and use the flat of a chef’s knife to crush the garlic, allowing the salt to grind the garlic into a fine paste. This can be used in the same way that you would use garlic from a garlic press, and may produce even better results.

A mortar and pestle can be used instead of a chef’s knife, but with patience, the knife will yield a good, smooth garlic paste.

Does Garlic Have to Be Minced?

Another misapprehension concerning garlic is the need to finely mince it for all recipes. You can chop your garlic as fine as you want. You can use larger pieces or smaller ones. The finer the mince, the less garlic you will want to use. If you don’t feel the need to hide the garlic pieces in your dish, then a coarser chop will often provide a better result.

You can also slice garlic. Often, when you use bigger pieces of garlic you can use more garlic without having it overwhelm a dish. This can allow you to get more of the nutritional benefits of garlic into your diet. How much garlic you can use depends on the particular garlic you have on hand. Some is stronger than others, so use your best judgment.

Grating Garlic

A small ginger grater or microplane grater can be used to grate garlic, giving results similar to garlic crushed with a garlic press. Some chefs from the Mediterranean area use the tines of a fork to grate garlic. If holding a little garlic cloves and trying to grate it sounds like a pain in the butt…it is. There is not much reason to grate garlic when a garlic press or the salting and pressing method described above will yield much the same results.

microplane graters

Better Than a Citrus Zester! The Microplane, a Multipurpose Tool

This article may contain one or more independently chosen Amazon affiliate links. See full disclosure. To zest a citrus fruit is an exercise in frustration without the proper tool. The zest is the outermost surface of...
Spiker kitchen skimmer, strainer, scooper

Why You Need a Spider Kitchen Utensil and What To Buy

This article may contain one or more independently chosen Amazon affiliate links. See full disclosure. A spider is a large ladle-shaped or almost semispherical-shaped mesh spoon with a long handle used as a strainer and skimmer. It’s like a wide shallow mesh bowl on a...

No post found