Why Do Americans Say Cookie Instead of Biscuit?

We Americans have the peculiar habit of calling a biscuit a cookie. At least according to British folks. Then, our biscuits are something else entirely. Where did we get the word cookie? It may seem logical to assume that the word cookie comes from the word cook, but, in fact, the two words are not related at all. The word cookie is Dutch in origin and is related to the word cake. The whole thing makes perfect sense. Read on to find out more, including why the British say biscuits and where crackers fit into all this.

See also: Origin of the Baker’s Dozen

various cookies or biscuits
Various Cookies or Biscuits

The Origin Of Cookie

The word cookie started in New Amsterdam (Nieuw Amsterdam), a Dutch colonial settlement on the southern tip of Manhattan Island. Established in 1625, it originated as a fur-trading settlement. There, traditional treats called koekjes were baked on all sorts of occasions. The word for cake, in Dutch, was koek. When the suffix -je was added, it meant “little cakes.”

These little cakes kept their name for quite some time, but things started changing in 1674 when the English got control of the colony and started Anglicizing everything.
 
What happened to New Amsterdam? It’s now New York! The first thing the English did was to change the name of the colony, in honor of the Duke of York, who is the guy who got it in his head to go to war against the Dutch in the first place.
 
 
Nevertheless, koekjes kept their name for a couple of decades. It took that long for most of the Dutch people in the colony to regularly speak English, which led to the word koekjes naturally evolving into a more English-sounding word.

According to written evidence (we only have written mentions to surmise when a word “officially” enters a language) an early iteration in English was cockies which then led to the word cookies. And that is how we got our English word for “little cakes,” which is really what a cookie is.

Like many English words, it is of basically Germanic origin. But in this instance, it came straight to America rather than entering the language earlier, via Britain.

The Duch sound for the long oo is written as oe, so the word koekje sounds pretty similar to the English word cookie. It sounds a bit like KOOOK-YES to my ear.

Dutch Koekjes and espresso for St. Nicholas Day
Koekjes and Espresso for the Dutch Holiday St. Nicholas Day

The Word Cake

The word koek, and thus cookie, is closely related to the work cake which came from the Old Norse word kaka, in the thirteenth century.

Although today we think of a cake as something made with very specific types of ingredients and techniques, the word originally had nothing to do with any specific recipe but referred to the shape: something round and flat on top, which may have been made from bread or other dough.

So, no, the word cookie has nothing to do with the word cook. The origin of the word cook is completely different, being of Latin origin. You can read more about words related to cook here at CulinaryLore. Now, in the next article, you can find out why the British Say Biscuit Instead of Cookie.

Collected References
 
1. Dunton-Downer, Leslie, Mary F. Rhinelander, and Kris Goodfellow. The English Is Coming!: How One Language Is Sweeping the World. New York: Touchstone Book, 2010.
2. Morton, Mark. Cupboard Love: A Dictionary of Culinary Curiousities. Toronto: Insomniac, 2004.
3. Mozeson, Isaac. The Word: The Dictionary That Reveals the Hebrew Sources of English. New York: SPI, 2000.
4. Editors of the American Heritage Dictionaries, More Word Histories and Mysteries: From Aardvark to Zombie. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2006.: manley : Manley, D. J. R. Biscuit, Cracker and Cookie Recipes for the Food Industry. Boca Raton, FL: CRC, 2001.
5. Edelstein, Sari. Food, Cuisine, and Cultural Competency for Culinary, Hospitality, and Nutrition Professionals. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett, 2011.
6. Wagenknecht, Edward. American Profile, 1900-1909. Amherst: University of Massachusetts, 1982.
7. Dotz, Warren, and Masud Husain. Meet Mr. Product: The Art of the Advertising Character. San Francisco: Chronicle, 2003.

You May Be Interested in These Articles